“Wit lies in recognizing the resemblance among things which differ and the difference between things which are alike.” Madame de Stael
When I was fourteen years old my parents had the idea that I might feel more connected to my Jewish heritage if they scraped together their hard earned cash and sent me to live on a kibbutz in Israel for a summer. My parents were concerned because I didn’t seem to be identifying with Judaism in any meaningful way. It was just a fact to me, like being White or Black or Indian or Asian.
I was thrilled by the idea of going to live on a kibbutz for a summer. Not having anything to do with getting in touch with Judaism; I just liked the whole idea of the communal thing. I imagined myself waking in the morning
to coffee, with cream freshly milked from a cow, and food stuff, (figs and nuts and apples and olives), grown and raised on the kibbutz; all lovingly served on rustic wooden tables, in tiled floor kitchens, with holy land sunlight streaming through the window, over looking a beautiful orchard.
Going to live on a kibbutz for the summer required an interview with the head of the Zionist organization that sponsored the program; this is the question that barred me entrance, “How do you feel about inter-religious marriage?”
I was stunned. I was fourteen. Who has a definitive opinion about something like that at the age of fourteen? I couldn’t figure out how that was any of his business. What’s that got to do with figs, and nuts, and communally living in harmony with nature? I found myself racking my brain for the “right” answer all the while knowing, somewhere deep down inside that the “right” answer, was the truth (whatever that truth may be).
As you might have surmised at this juncture, I wasn’t the most sophisticated thinker at the age of fourteen. So, I told him, “If two people love each other, I don’t see why it should matter what religion they are”. Bong! Wrong Answer!
So it would seem, the chosen people would not be choosing me to “represent”. I’m pretty sure this was the first time in my life that I began to identify and ponder the notion that I was a blood descendant of Jesus, who (like me), was Jewish and (like me) was not inclined to provide the “right” answers just to gain the favor and privilege of the powerful rabbi’s and Romans of his day.
My first experience with antisemitism was when I was 8 years old. We had these neighbors who would generously invite me to join them and their children on some summer afternoons; and they would take us to The Yacht Club. I loved the Yacht Club. It was like heaven to me. The water from the Long Island sound was filtered (unlike the
public beach my family belonged to) so there was no yucky seaweed or jellyfish. And you never had to bring towels, or beach chairs or anything. It was all there and best of all, they had Magic Waiters!
These magic waiters would come to you, as you sat on a chaise lounge, dripping on your clean, white towel and you could order a soda and when he/she arrived back with your ice cold beverage all you had to do was sign this little slip of paper and magically it was yours. There was no asking your Mom for money, or waiting in lines, jumping up and down on the hot concrete because you forgot to wear your flip-flops.
I begged my parents relentless to join the Yacht Club and they would always reply, “We can’t join the Yacht Club we’re Jewish”. I always thought it was some kind of excuse. And then one day, it happened. I was playing with my friends in the water there and another friend, that I went to school with, slid down the slide, jump up out of the water and [without an ounce of malice] said, “Stefanie! What are you doing here? I thought you were Jewish?”
I was mortified. When something like that happens you feel really stupid. Did I really think I, and my family, would be privy to that kind of opulence? To suddenly realize what my parents had been saying; that there were places we weren’t welcome and didn’t belong. I had never really understood there was any major difference between us (Christians, Jews, Black or White) because I didn’t make those kinds of distinction. Apparently, the world did and I didn’t have a choice in the matter.
There was a box I belonged in. My parents kept telling me about this box but I didn’t understand. I can honestly say, when that happened it was my first realization that no matter how I defined myself, no matter what I did, or who I became, there was a box that other people would put me in. The box was mine whether I claimed it or not.
For most of my life I just ignored the box, mostly because the whole notion of the box just pissed me off. I wasn’t concerned with heritage, or religion, or history, or anything that had the power to define me. I simply didn’t want to be tied to anything or anyone that could tell me who I was without my consent.
Then again, there’s that history, millions of Jews, going back thousands of years. My blood, my relatives, my ancestors, who when faced with slavery, pogroms, oppression, discrimination, antisemitism, and ultimately the horror of systematic extermination; (all of whom, no matter how they defined themselves), were met with the same gruesome fate; simply by the truth of their blood.
When it comes to shit like that, no one cares how you define yourself. Myself, Bob Dylan, Leonard Cohen, Ann Frank, Albert Einstein, Emma Goldman, Eli Wiesel, Jerry Jeff Walker, Kinky Friedman, Natalie Portman, Mother Mary and Jesus [himself] would have all be on the same train, headed to the same place; and nothing we had ever done, would have distinguished us or saved us; which makes the question of how one defines oneself almost ludicrous in that context.
Nevertheless, as the years went on and I did define myself, I didn’t think much anymore about organized religion one way or the other. It was just another fact about the world that I didn’t have much interest in. On some levels I began to believe that all these distinction, [religion, ethnicity, and nationality] are just divisive and serve to tear humanity apart rather than bring us together. But now I’m not sure I believe that anymore.
This past month for the first time ever, I decided to host a Passover Seder. I’m not really sure what inspired me. Since I haven’t been to a Passover Seder in years; and the only thing I had to go on were my memories of doing them as a child every year with my family. My friends were thrill. Of those invited only three had ever attended a Passover Seder before. The only Jew in attendance was me.
My parents were overjoyed and to help with the festivities; my father put together a “Passover care package” which arrived via UPS bless his heart! I made copies of the Seder book he sent me, and lit the Shabbat candles, and served the special Passover wine. We dipped the parsley and ate the haroset-matzo sandwiches. I struggled through the prayers in Hebrew and then repeating them in English, as I had been taught. And, as in my family, we went around the table and all my friends read the story of the exodus of the Jews from Israel.
But it was my friend’s children who intrigued me the most because they asked questions Jewish kids would never ask. Like, “Why did the Pharaoh want to kill the Jews if they were already slaves?” Jewish kids don’t ever ask why people want to kill them. Jewish kids just know that occasionally folks just take to doing it. Christian kids want a reason.
After the Seder I brought out all the traditional foods I remembered eating on Passover; Matzo ball soup, potato latkes, my friends even tried the gefilte fish with my fathers homemade horseradish (an a acquired taste at best).
What moved me was how open my friends were to all of it For the first time in my life I experienced being Jewish not as something that separated me, and alienated me, and made me different, but as something ancient I was connected to. And now I was taking that connection and connecting all these people I love, not just to this ancient ritual, but to me and to one another. I credit my friends for this realization because it was them, not I that were so embracing, accepting, and genuinely curious.
What my family doesn’t know is that whenever they would make me go to synagogue (and to this day), when I witness the unveiling of the Torah, I well up inside and it takes everything in me not to cry. I am viscerally moved and I never understood before now, why.
It’s the ancientness, the ceremony, the blood; this ritual that goes back thousands of years which perhaps is not just intended to connect us to God,
or our history, or our heritage but to one another; and it doesn’t really matter if who we’re connecting to is Jewish, or Christian, or Muslim, or Hindu or Buddhist, or Naturalist, or Atheist or Agnostic. What matters is we’re connecting.
We are given a choice, we can use these things to connect and share with one another, or we can use them to divide and fracture us; but either way it’s up to
us.
Next year I plan to host another Passover Seder and as is the tradition of Passover, all will be welcome at my table.
























